Bhāratīya Jñāna Paramparā · Volume 3
Volume 3: Darśana Darpaṇa
Schools of Indian Philosophy
Nikhil Kumar Rajput
Nyāya, Vaiśeṣika, Sāṃkhya, Yoga, Mīmāṃsā and the Grammarians, Vedānta, Cārvāka, Buddhist, Jain and Śaiva Philosophy
In the reading lists Start here (book 2 of 5) and Philosophy and contemplative traditions (book 2 of 5)
13 chapters
Contents¶
Front matter
Chapters
Chapter 1: Introduction — The Panorama of Indian Philosophy
- 1.1 The Meaning of Darśana
- 1.2 Characteristic Features of Indian Philosophical Inquiry
- 1.3 The Classification of Darśanas
- 1.4 The Historical Development of Philosophical Thought
- 1.5 The Philosophical Questions
- 1.6 Epistemological Foundations: The Pramāṇas
- 1.7 The Integrative Vision
- 1.8 The Concept of Tattva: Reality in Indian Thought
- 1.9 The Puruṣārthas and Philosophical Inquiry
- 1.10 The Common Doctrinal Heritage
- 1.11 The Methodology of Philosophical Inquiry
- 1.12 The Darśanas in Comparative Perspective
- 1.13 Modern Uses of the Darśanas
- 1.14 The Guru-Śiṣya Paramparā in Philosophical Transmission
- 1.15 The Philosophical Vocabulary of Darśana
- 1.16 Philosophy, the Other Sciences and Society
- 1.17 Organization and Scope of This Volume
Chapter 2: Nyāya — The Science of Logic and Epistemology
- 2.1 Historical Background
- 2.2 The Sixteen Categories (Padārthas)
- 2.3 The Nyāya Theory of Perception (Pratyakṣa)
- 2.4 The Nyāya Theory of Inference (Anumāna)
- 2.5 The Nyāya Theory of Fallacies (Hetvābhāsa)
- 2.6 The Nyāya Theory of Comparison (Upamāna)
- 2.7 The Nyāya Theory of Verbal Testimony (Śabda)
- 2.8 Nyāya Theory of Causation
- 2.9 The Self (Ātman)
- 2.10 God (Īśvara)
- 2.11 Navya-Nyāya — The New Logic
- 2.12 The Nyāya Theory of Debate
- 2.13 The Purpose and Legacy of Nyāya
Chapter 3: Vaiśeṣika — Atomism and the Categories of Reality
- 3.1 Historical Background and Foundational Texts
- 3.2 The Seven Categories of Reality (Sapta Padārtha)
- 3.3 The Atomic Theory (Paramāṇu-Vāda)
- 3.4 Causation (Ārambhavāda)
- 3.5 Space, Time and Mind
- 3.6 The Vaiśeṣika Theory of Motion
- 3.7 Adṛṣṭa, God and the Cycle of the World
- 3.8 Vaiśeṣika Epistemology and Its Relation to Nyāya
- 3.9 Vaiśeṣika and the Philosophy of Science
- 3.10 Inter-School Debates
- 3.11 Philosophical Assessment of Vaiśeṣika
Chapter 4: Sāṃkhya — The Philosophy of Cosmic Enumeration
- 4.1 Historical Background
- 4.2 Suffering and the Inquiry
- 4.3 Two Ultimate Principles: Puruṣa and Prakṛti
- 4.4 The Three Guṇas
- 4.5 The Pre-existence of the Effect (Satkāryavāda)
- 4.6 Manifestation: The Twenty-Five Tattvas
- 4.7 Knowledge, the Inner Organ and the Theory of Reflection
- 4.8 Dispositions and the Subtle Body
- 4.9 Liberation (Kaivalya)
- 4.10 The Question of God in Sāṃkhya
- 4.11 Sāṃkhya in the Bhagavad Gītā and the Epics
- 4.12 Critics and Comparisons
- 4.13 An Assessment
Chapter 5: Yoga — The Discipline of Union and Liberation
- 5.1 Historical Background
- 5.2 Yoga and Sāṃkhya: Metaphysical Foundations
- 5.3 The Structure of the Yoga Sūtra
- 5.4 Citta and Its Modifications (Vṛttis)
- 5.5 The Five Kleśas (Afflictions)
- 5.6 The Yoga Theory of Karma and Rebirth
- 5.7 Aṣṭāṅga Yoga — The Eight Limbs
- 5.8 Types of Samādhi
- 5.9 The Concept of īśvara in Yoga
- 5.10 The Vibhūti Pāda: Supernatural Powers (Siddhis)
- 5.11 Kaivalya — Absolute Liberation
- 5.12 The Yoga Theory of Perception and Consciousness
- 5.13 Yoga and the Bhagavad Gītā
- 5.14 Comparative Analysis: Yoga and Buddhist Meditation
- 5.15 Later Yoga: Haṭha and Rāja Yoga
- 5.16 Yoga’s Enduring Relevance
Chapter 6: Pūrva Mīmāṃsā and the Grammarians — Vedic Hermeneutics and the Philosophy of Language
- 6.1 Historical Background and Significance
- 6.2 Two Sub-Schools: Bhāṭṭa and Prābhākara
- 6.3 The Concept of Dharma
- 6.4 Vedic Sentences and Injunctions
- 6.5 Principles of Interpretation
- 6.6 Epistemology: The Six Pramāṇas
- 6.7 The Doctrine of Apauruṣeyatva — The Authorless Vedas
- 6.8 Language: Words, Meanings and Sentences
- 6.9 Mīmāṃsā’s Theory of the Self (Ātman)
- 6.10 The Question of God in Mīmāṃsā
- 6.11 The Mīmāṃsā Theory of Apūrva: A Detailed Analysis
- 6.12 The Analysis of Ritual Structure
- 6.13 Kumārila Bhaṭṭa: The Great Defender of the Vedas
- 6.14 Prabhākara: An Alternative Mīmāṃsā Voice
- 6.15 Mīmāṃsā and the Theory of Speech Acts
- 6.16 The Mīmāṃsā Debate with Vedānta
- 6.17 Mīmāṃsā’s Influence on Law and Culture
- 6.18 The Grammarians: Bhartṛhari and the Philosophy of the Word
Chapter 7: Vedānta — Advaita, Viśiṣṭādvaita and Dvaita
- 7.1 Introduction: The End of the Vedas
- 7.2 The Triple Foundation and the Central Questions
- 7.3 Advaita Vedānta — Śaṅkara’s Non-Dualism
- 7.4 Advaita after Śaṅkara: The Later Schools and the Dialectical Turn
- 7.5 Viśiṣṭādvaita — Rāmānuja’s Qualified Non-Dualism
- 7.6 Dvaita — Madhva’s Dualism
- 7.7 The Three Schools Compared
- 7.8 Vedānta and Modern Philosophy
Chapter 8: Other Schools of Vedānta and Related Theologies
- 8.1 Introduction: Beyond the Three Great Schools
- 8.2 The Early Bhedābheda Tradition
- 8.3 Dvaitādvaita — Nimbārka’s Dualistic Non-Dualism
- 8.4 Śuddhādvaita — Vallabha’s Pure Non-Dualism
- 8.5 Acintya Bhedābheda — Caitanya’s Inconceivable Difference-and-Non-difference
- 8.6 Śaiva Vedānta and the Śaiva Siddhānta
- 8.7 The Hermeneutical Methods of the Vedānta Schools
- 8.8 Modern Vedānta
- 8.9 Comparison and Common Ground
Chapter 9: Cārvāka — The Philosophy of Materialism
Chapter 10: Buddhist Philosophy — The Middle Way
- 10.1 Introduction
- 10.2 The Foundational Teachings
- 10.3 Early Schools and the Abhidharma
- 10.4 The Major Philosophical Schools in Later Classification
- 10.5 Mahāyāna and the Madhyamaka
- 10.6 Yogācāra (Vijñānavāda)
- 10.7 Buddhist Epistemology: Dignāga and Dharmakīrti
- 10.8 Buddhist Ethics and Soteriology
- 10.9 The Debate with Brahmanical Schools
- 10.10 The Decline of Buddhism in India
- 10.11 Legacy and Influence
Chapter 11: Jain Philosophy — The Doctrine of Many-Sidedness
- 11.1 Introduction: The Path of the Conquerors
- 11.2 Umāsvāti and the Tattvārthasūtra
- 11.3 Jain Metaphysics: The Nature of Reality
- 11.4 Anekāntavāda: The Many-Sidedness of Reality
- 11.5 Syādvāda: Qualified Predication
- 11.6 Nayavāda: The Theory of Standpoints
- 11.7 Kundakunda and the Two Standpoints
- 11.8 Jain Epistemology
- 11.9 Jain Ethics: The Path of Ahiṃsā
- 11.10 Jain Philosophy and Other Schools
- 11.11 Legacy and Continuing Relevance
Chapter 12: Śaiva Philosophy — The Siddhānta and the Doctrine of Recognition
Chapter 13: Comparing the Schools — Knowledge, Error, Debate and Conclusions
- 13.1 Introduction: Why Epistemology Became Central
- 13.2 What Counts as a Means of Knowledge
- 13.3 Perception and Conceptual Construction
- 13.4 Inference Compared
- 13.5 The Validity of Knowledge: Svataḥ and Parataḥ
- 13.6 Theories of Error (Khyātivāda)
- 13.7 The Tradition of Debate
- 13.8 Debating about Debate: Norms, Manuals and Thesis-less Refutation
- 13.9 Universals and Causation
- 13.10 Conclusion: What the Comparison Shows
Back matter
Preface¶
This is Volume 3 of the series Bhāratīya Jñāna Paramparā: Darśana Darpaṇa: Schools of Indian Philosophy. It introduces the classical schools of Indian philosophy — Nyāya, Vaiśeṣika, Sāṃkhya, Yoga, Pūrva Mīmāṃsā and Vedānta, together with the philosophy of the Grammarians — and the traditions that Brahmanical authors called nāstika: the materialist Cārvāka, and Buddhist and Jain philosophy. A chapter on Śaiva philosophy — the dualist Śaiva Siddhānta and the non-dualist school of Recognition (pratyabhijñā) — follows, with an account of its Tamil form, and a final chapter compares the schools’ theories of knowledge (pramāṇa), error and debate and draws the volume’s conclusions.
The book tries to present each school on its own terms and in its own best arguments, and to give the reader a sense of the long debate among them. Dates are given according to mainstream academic scholarship, with traditional dates identified as such. Quotations from primary texts are limited to passages whose wording and reference could be checked; claims that ancient texts anticipated modern science have been avoided, and comparisons with modern philosophy are offered as analogies. The social setting of philosophy, including restrictions of learning by caste and gender, is noted where it bears on the subject.
This edition has been revised to correct errors found in an earlier draft, and the Buddhist and Jain chapters in particular have been expanded. Later additions are the chapter on Śaiva philosophy and accounts of Advaita after Śaṅkara, of the method of Navya-Nyāya and its early-modern successors, and of the theory of debate; in the latest revision, sections that treated the same topic twice were merged, the arguments of the Cārvākas and the Vaiśeṣikas were set out more fully, and the volume’s omissions — above all Indo-Islamic thought and much regional-language philosophy — are stated in the Introduction. It remains an introduction: specialists will find simplifications, and every primary-text quotation should be checked against a critical edition; the editions used are listed at the end, with a chronology and a guide to further reading.
Transliteration and abbreviations. Sanskrit, Pali and Prakrit are given in the International Alphabet of Sanskrit Transliteration (IAST): long vowels are marked with a macron (ā, ī, ū), retroflex consonants with a dot below (ṭ, ḍ, ṇ, ṣ), the palatal sibilant as ś, anusvāra as ṃ and visarga as ḥ; vocalic r is ṛ. Tamil follows the transliteration of the Tamil Lexicon (so ḻ, ṉ, ṟ). Names of modern authors and places are given in their usual English spelling. References to primary texts are by chapter and verse or sūtra; in a few tables NS, VS, MS and ṚV stand for the Nyāya Sūtra, Vaiśeṣika Sūtra, Mīmāṃsā Sūtra and Ṛgveda. Dates are CE unless marked BCE.
Nikhil Kumar Rajput
Ramanujan College, University of Delhi
Guru Pūrṇimā, 2026