Bhāratīya Jñāna Paramparā · Volume 18
Volume 18: Rājanīti and Dharmaśāstra
Polity and Law
Nikhil Kumar Rajput
Statecraft, kingship and law in the Arthaśāstra and Dharmaśāstra, in Buddhist, Jain and Islamic traditions, and from colonial codification to the Constitution
In the reading list Society, polity and economy (book 1 of 5)
20 chapters
Contents¶
Front matter
Chapters
Chapter 1: Introduction: Polity and Law in Indian Traditions
- 1.1 Key Terms
- 1.2 The Sources
- 1.3 Chronology
- 1.4 Rājanīti and Dharmaśāstra: Two Traditions
- 1.5 A Vocabulary of Rule
- 1.6 Beyond the King
- 1.7 Voices of Dissent
- 1.8 How Modern Scholarship Came to These Texts
- 1.9 A Note on Translation and Citation
- 1.10 Approach
- 1.11 Indian Traditions in Comparative Perspective
- 1.12 The Plan of the Book
- 1.13 Summary
- Further Reading
Chapter 2: Ṛta, Satya and Dharma: The Vedic Foundations
Chapter 3: The Arthaśāstra: Text, Date and Structure
- 3.1 What Is “Arthaśāstra”?
- 3.2 Author and Date
- 3.3 Rediscovery and Editions
- 3.4 Structure
- 3.5 The Contents in Outline
- 3.6 The Arthaśāstra and the Mauryan State
- 3.7 Style, Audience and Ideology
- 3.8 Reception
- 3.9 Kāmandaka’s Nītisāra
- 3.10 Reading the Arthaśāstra Today
- 3.11 Principal Passages
- 3.12 Summary
- Further Reading
Chapter 4: The Saptāṅga Theory of the State
- 4.1 The Seven Elements
- 4.2 The King
- 4.3 The Ministers
- 4.4 The Countryside and Its People
- 4.5 The Fort
- 4.6 The Treasury
- 4.7 The Army
- 4.8 The Ally
- 4.9 The Calamities of the Elements
- 4.10 The Enemy and the Three Powers
- 4.11 The Saptāṅga in Other Traditions
- 4.12 An Organic Image
- 4.13 The Saptāṅga in Later Thought and in Historiography
- 4.14 Summary
- Further Reading
Chapter 5: Rājadharma: Kingship in the Epics and the Śāstras
- 5.1 The Origin of Kingship
- 5.2 The King’s Duties
- 5.3 The King’s Self-Discipline
- 5.4 Coronation, Chaplain and Council
- 5.5 Rājadharma in the Epics
- 5.6 Succession and Regency
- 5.7 Kings, Temples and Gods
- 5.8 Limits on Royal Power
- 5.9 Women and Kingship
- 5.10 The King as Giver
- 5.11 Kings in History
- 5.12 The Tamil South and the Early Medieval State
- 5.13 Principal Passages
- 5.14 Summary
- Further Reading
Chapter 6: Revenue, Administration and the Political Economy of the Arthaśāstra
- 6.1 Vārttā: Economics among the Sciences
- 6.2 Revenue
- 6.3 Land, Settlement and Production
- 6.4 Markets and Merchants
- 6.5 Money
- 6.6 Wages, Labour and Slavery
- 6.7 Calamities and Relief
- 6.8 Forests and Forest Peoples
- 6.9 Trade and the Wider World
- 6.10 Controlling Officials
- 6.11 Town and Country
- 6.12 Assessment
- 6.13 Summary
- Further Reading
Chapter 7: The Circle of Kings: Diplomacy, Intelligence and War
- 7.1 The Circle of Kings
- 7.2 The Six Measures of Policy
- 7.3 The Four Means
- 7.4 Envoys
- 7.5 Spies and Covert Action
- 7.6 The Maṇḍala after Kauṭilya
- 7.7 Intelligence in Later Indian States
- 7.8 War
- 7.9 Righteous War and Its Limits
- 7.10 Diplomacy in Practice
- 7.11 Buddhist and Jain Views of War
- 7.12 War in Tamil Tradition
- 7.13 Spoils, Captives and the Conquered
- 7.14 Comparisons and Reception
- 7.15 Summary
- Further Reading
Chapter 8: Kingship, Dhamma and Law in the Buddhist and Jain Traditions
- 8.1 The World of the Śramaṇas
- 8.2 The Buddha and the Vajjian Assembly
- 8.3 The Origin of Kingship: The Aggañña Sutta
- 8.4 The Wheel-Turning King
- 8.5 The Saṅgha as a Legal Community
- 8.6 Aśoka’s Dhamma
- 8.7 Buddhist Kingship beyond India
- 8.8 Jain Political and Legal Thought
- 8.9 Later Buddhist Advice to Kings
- 8.10 Monasteries, Patronage and Decline
- 8.11 Assessment
- 8.12 Principal Passages
- 8.13 Summary
- Further Reading
Chapter 9: The Dharmaśāstra Tradition: Sources, Texts and Interpreters
- 9.1 Dharma in the Śāstras
- 9.2 The Sources of Dharma
- 9.3 The Development of the Literature
- 9.4 The Three Divisions
- 9.5 Interpreting the Texts
- 9.6 Paṇḍits, Assemblies and Written Rulings
- 9.7 Dharmaśāstra and Arthaśāstra
- 9.8 Was Dharmaśāstra Law?
- 9.9 Regional Traditions
- 9.10 Dharmaśāstra and the State: The Case of Nepal
- 9.11 Beyond the Subcontinent: Law Books in Southeast Asia
- 9.12 From Manuscript to Print
- 9.13 P. V. Kane and Modern Scholarship
- 9.14 Summary
- Further Reading
Chapter 10: The Manusmṛti
Chapter 11: Yājñavalkya, Nārada and the Schools of Hindu Law
- 11.1 The Yājñavalkyasmṛti
- 11.2 The Nāradasmṛti
- 11.3 Bṛhaspati and Kātyāyana
- 11.4 Other Smṛtis
- 11.5 The Mitākṣarā
- 11.6 The Dāyabhāga
- 11.7 Partition and the Joint Family in Practice
- 11.8 Women’s Property in the Commentaries
- 11.9 Daughters as Heirs
- 11.10 Sapiṇḍa Relationship
- 11.11 The “Schools” of Hindu Law
- 11.12 The Smṛtis in the Reform Debates
- 11.13 From Commentary to Statute
- 11.14 Summary
- Further Reading
Chapter 12: Vyavahāra: Courts, Procedure and Proof
- 12.1 The Courts
- 12.2 The Eighteen Titles of Law
- 12.3 The Course of a Lawsuit
- 12.4 The Means of Proof
- 12.5 Ordeals and Oaths
- 12.6 Courts in Practice
- 12.7 Bringing a Defendant to Court
- 12.8 Representation and Costs
- 12.9 The Language of the Courts
- 12.10 The Judge
- 12.11 Assessment
- 12.12 Principal Passages
- 12.13 Summary
- Further Reading
Chapter 13: Debt, Contract, Property and Inheritance
- 13.1 Debt
- 13.2 Deposits, Sales and Gifts
- 13.3 Partnership, Guilds and Conventions
- 13.4 Wages, Service and Slavery
- 13.5 Land, Boundaries and Cattle
- 13.6 Lost Property, Treasure and Escheat
- 13.7 Gambling and Betting
- 13.8 Houses and Neighbours
- 13.9 Inheritance and Partition
- 13.10 The Arthaśāstra’s Private Law
- 13.11 Assessment
- 13.12 Principal Passages
- 13.13 Summary
- Further Reading
Chapter 14: Crime, Punishment and Penance
- 14.1 The Justification of Punishment
- 14.2 Classes of Offence
- 14.3 Punishment by Varṇa
- 14.4 Forms of Punishment
- 14.5 The Arthaśāstra’s “Removal of Thorns”
- 14.6 Theft, Violence and Sudden Death
- 14.7 Penance
- 14.8 Punishment in Later Indian States
- 14.9 From Daṇḍanīti to the Penal Code
- 14.10 Principal Passages
- 14.11 Summary
- Further Reading
Chapter 15: Family, Saṃskāra and Women in Dharmaśāstra
- 15.1 The Stages of Life
- 15.2 The Saṃskāras
- 15.3 Marriage
- 15.4 Wives and Widows
- 15.5 Women in the Arthaśāstra
- 15.6 Women’s Property and Inheritance
- 15.7 Women in the Buddhist and Jain Orders
- 15.8 Devadāsīs
- 15.9 Adoption and Maintenance
- 15.10 Women’s Voices
- 15.11 Women as Patrons, Authors and Reformers
- 15.12 From Strīdhana to Dowry
- 15.13 Polygyny, Supersession and Monogamy
- 15.14 Reform and Codification
- 15.15 Assessment
- 15.16 Summary
- Further Reading
Chapter 16: Custom, Community and Local Justice
Chapter 17: Kingdoms on Record: Charters, Scribes and Statecraft, c. 500–1700
- 17.1 The Charter as a Legal Instrument
- 17.2 Buying Land in Gupta Bengal
- 17.3 Scribes and Record-Keepers
- 17.4 The Lekhapaddhati: A Scribe’s Formulary from Gujarat
- 17.5 Medieval Treatises on Kingship
- 17.6 A Historian’s Kingdom: Kalhaṇa’s Kashmir
- 17.7 Vijayanagara: Empire, Nāyakas and a King’s Advice
- 17.8 Lineage and Service: The Rajput Kingdoms
- 17.9 The Ahom State in Assam
- 17.10 Kings as Arbiters: Settlements in Stone
- 17.11 Assessment
- 17.12 Summary
- Further Reading
Chapter 18: Sharīʿa, Siyāsa and Sovereignty: Islamic Law and the Indo-Persian State, c. 1200–1800
- 18.1 Sharīʿa and Fiqh
- 18.2 Crime and Punishment: Ḥadd, Qiṣāṣ and Taʿzīr
- 18.3 The Delhi Sultanate
- 18.4 Persian Political Thought
- 18.5 The Mughal Empire
- 18.6 Endowments, Shrines and Grants
- 18.7 Dharmaśāstra under the Sultans and the Mughals
- 18.8 Islamic Law beyond Delhi
- 18.9 Crisis and Reform: Shāh Walī Allāh
- 18.10 Successor States
- 18.11 The Sikh Polity: Khālsā, Gurmatā, Misls and the Lahore State
- 18.12 Assessment
- 18.13 Summary
- Further Reading
Chapter 19: The Company and the Codes: The Making of Anglo-Indian Law, 1772–1947
- 19.1 Hastings’s Plan of 1772
- 19.2 Translating the Śāstras
- 19.3 The Company’s Courts
- 19.4 Anglo-Hindu Law
- 19.5 Anglo-Muhammadan Law
- 19.6 Codification and Reform
- 19.7 Lawyers, Courts and the National Movement
- 19.8 Law in the Princely States
- 19.9 Portuguese and French India
- 19.10 Assessment
- 19.11 Summary
- Further Reading
Chapter 20: The Constitution and the Classical Legacy
- 20.1 The Constitution’s Break with Hierarchy
- 20.2 Dalit Legal and Political Thought after Ambedkar
- 20.3 The Directive Principles
- 20.4 Symbols of the Republic
- 20.5 Codifying Hindu Law
- 20.6 Personal Law and the Uniform Civil Code
- 20.7 Religion, Endowments and the State
- 20.8 The Courts and the Classical Texts
- 20.9 Kauṭilya in Modern India
- 20.10 Dharma, Rāmarājya and Modern Politics
- 20.11 Criminal Law after Independence
- 20.12 Women in the Republic
- 20.13 Conclusion
- 20.14 Summary
- Further Reading
Back matter
Preface¶
This is Volume 18 of the series Bhāratīya Jñāna Paramparā: Rājanīti and Dharmaśāstra: Polity and Law. It surveys Indian traditions of political thought and law from the Vedic period to the Constitution of the Republic of India: the Arthaśāstra and the later literature on polity; the theory of kingship in the śāstras and the epics; Buddhist and Jain ideas of the righteous ruler and the law of the monastic order; the Dharmaśāstra literature, from the Dharmasūtras and the Manusmṛti to the medieval commentaries and digests; courts, procedure, contract, property, inheritance, crime and the family in classical law; custom, caste and village institutions; the charters, scribes and statecraft of the medieval kingdoms; Islamic law and the Indo-Persian state of the Sultanate and the Mughals; the making of “Anglo-Hindu” and “Anglo-Muhammadan” law under British rule; and the Constitution’s encounter with this inheritance.
After an introduction, the chapters fall into four groups: the foundations of Indian political thought, the Arthaśāstra’s science of the state and the Buddhist and Jain alternatives to it (Chapters 2–8); the Dharmaśāstra literature (Chapters 9–11); the classical law of procedure, property, crime, the family and custom (Chapters 12–16); and the history of law and government from the medieval regional kingdoms and the Delhi Sultanate to the Republic (Chapters 17–20). Primary texts are quoted only where both the wording and the reference could be confirmed against a standard edition; elsewhere they are paraphrased, with the reference given. Dates follow current scholarship, with traditional dates labelled as such; in particular, the Arthaśāstra is treated as a composite text of c. 50 BCE–300 CE and the Manusmṛti as a work of about the second century CE, following Patrick Olivelle. The volume does not claim that the classical texts “anticipated” modern constitutions, welfare states or human rights; comparisons with other traditions are presented as comparisons.
The texts discussed here are, among other things, charters of social hierarchy, and the volume does not hide this. It sets out their provisions on varṇa, untouchability and women with references to the primary sources, and it gives space to the critics — from the Buddha to B. R. Ambedkar and modern feminist and Dalit scholars — who exposed and opposed them. It also tries to give due weight to the real intellectual achievements of the traditions: the Arthaśāstra’s analysis of the state, the Dharmaśāstras’ law of procedure and property, and the many forms of local self-government recorded in inscriptions.
References to standard editions, translations and studies — among others by P. V. Kane, Robert Lingat, J. D. M. Derrett, Ludo Rocher, Richard Lariviere, Patrick Olivelle, Donald Davis, R. P. Kangle, Thomas Trautmann, Mark McClish, R. S. Sharma, Romila Thapar, Upinder Singh, Uma Chakravarti, Muzaffar Alam and Marc Galanter — are given in the text and collected in the select bibliography, which is meant as a guide to further reading. A list of abbreviations follows the table of contents; a glossary, a chronology, brief notes on persons and a guide to the principal sources are provided at the end. No survey of this size can be exhaustive or free of error, and every quotation should, before scholarly use, be checked against a critical edition.
Nikhil Kumar Rajput
Ramanujan College, University of Delhi
Guru Pūrṇimā, 2026